Just because something is obvious doesn’t mean it’s right.
Obviously.
That’s a 90-ish minute video by evolutionary biologist Forrest Valkai goes over the science of sex and gender. The TL/DW version is that the quote here is exactly right. Sex is fuzzy and before you could even start to say something like that it’s binary you first need to establish which of the many sex markers you’re going to use and why you’re excluding the other ones, gender is a social construct which is not the same as sex, and any modern biology textbook above a high-school level will say exactly that. Not implicitly, but explicitly.
If it’s the kind of thing you’re interested in and you’ve got 90 minutes to spare you could do worse than listen to a scientist lay it out.
Forrest is great at explaining complex topics
Is he the new CGP Grey?
I dunno about new, I just know him from the Atheist Experience call in shows. He’s always so positive and energetic, even when he’s laying an intellectual smackdown on a creationist caller.
Everybody knows a string has 0 mass and air resistance is negligible, it’s basic physics!
First assume the cow is spherical and traveling through a vacuum.
replacing standard with gender gives me a little giggle, because this is obviously how gender works
Again, 12 year old grown ups and their 12 year old views
It’s always the ‘common sense’ crowd that needs to reduce everything to the most basic and mostly binary understanding of the universe. Good vs evil, us vs them.
Anything that upsets that proverbial apple cart is evil because it’s not part of their existing world view.
Y’all don’t learn about intersex in sex ed on the last years of middle school?
uh, 30ish years ago no. my education did not address intersex people until the bachelor’s level 4th year genetics class i somehow got into even though i didn’t have the prereqs.
Mine did, 30 years ago in 95 (and it’s wild that 95 was not 10years ago).
XXY, XYY and other stuff.
There are plenty of well educated trans and homo phobes out there. Making it about education level sounds classist/elitist and alienating to the many well meaning intelligent people who didn’t have the opportunity to reach levels of higher education.
There are plenty of racist, misogynistic, and bigoted “educated” people.
You don’t need a university classroom to teach you about gender or sex or being a decent human being. All of this information is readily available to the public, in fact, if it takes a Masters or PhD to understand what is yes- in fact basic biology and gender theory, then you’re doing something wrong. And by basic I mean, human biological sex can also be complex and gender is a social construct. It’s an afternoon course not six plus fucking years of schooling.
Yes, oversimplification is weaponized but framing like this can come off as insulting and makes it sound more complex than it needs to be.
It’s a recurring problem with humans that something makes them feel bad, and then they stop listening.
Someone who feels bad about how they didn’t go to college, and then stops listening to the contents, is a fool.
You are correct that there are many such people, and we should probably avoid triggering them, but it’s kind of frustrating we have to constantly walk on eggshells lest someone’s fragile ego cracks and a monster comes out.
Not only walking on eggshells, we are literally being forced to put our children in danger of infectious diseases that we got rid of a long fucking time ago
I mean you’re not wrong. It’d be great to live in a perfect world. This method has worked great for leftists and liberals alike in winning friends.
Perhaps because I’ve walked the line between workers rights and blue collar backgrounds I have a little more empathy for meeting people where they’re at then demanding they adhere to academic standard. I’ve never found arrogance, perceived or real, to be a very helpful tool in organizing or building community. Flies and honey and all that jazz.
While I agree that we shouldn’t alienate people with elitism, I think k this is a fair criticism.
Basic biology has the connotation that it’s something everyone should know and grasp.
The reality is that basic biology is simplified, not factual. That should be pointed out. The educated or intelligent ones, should understand the distinction, even if they disagree. The uneducated can either switch off or be educated.
Allowing misinformation to proliferate is a bigger problem, in my view, than alienating people that don’t want to listen or learn.
Hail science!
There’s no genders, we are just atoms in a certain formation.
They are all in the head.
“Basic biology” mfs when intermediate biology comes along
“most basic gender science will reveal a vaguely bimodal distribution of gender for some gendered characteristics.” is my untested hypothesis. I’m too eepy to go collect data.
Scientifically, I’d say it’s mostly about male/female but that there are exceptions. Socially, I’d say that we are all taught to play act when young and some roles are preferable to us as we age, regardless of science. All the world’s a stage. May everyone feel like they fit. Peace.
Scientifically it’s multiple continuums with trends across a broad population correlated with foetal and pubescent hormone exposure that is poorly applicable to individuals. But sure let’s reduce that complexity all down to „male/female“ scientifically.
I don’t want you to understand what relativity or supernova is, how to grow crops, how to make operation or how to fix a sink so don’t make me understand what is biology past middle school. Just saying, don’t want to hurt anybody but maybe it’s not people problem but education problem. Stop blaming people that they were educated certain way and they accepted truth presented by public education system, blame country that is educating people this way. You can’t change people but you can change future of your country.
Removed by mod
Who hurt you
Asking the real question
