Had a group that would play DnD 3.5, where you need to roll to confirm crits (20 auto hits, roll again against AC to crit). We ended up rolling to confirm fumbles as well because catastrophic failure doesn’t just happen 5% of the time. Imagine 5% of your army accidentally chopping their foot off or beheading their nearest kinsman every few seconds.
That’s the way I handle it. A 1 on the die is automatic failure, but roll again and on another 1, it’s catastrophic.
That’s a 0.25% chance. Seems too low. I’d just repeat the test and if it results in a failure, it’s a critical. That way the difficulty of the test would factor in.
1 catastrophic failure out of 400 attempts when you are trained in the task seems… Very high.
I teach sword, if a critical fumble happened 1 out of 400 strikes I would have given up practicing ages ago due to the fear of maiming myself.
Differing goals. For realism, you’re right. Many systems forego a critical failure entirely because of that.
But fumbles are fun and dramatic. So while 1 out of 20 is excessive, having that danger lurking in every roll can be exciting. Of course you don’t want to chop off limbs at every fumble, but chucking a weapon, breaking a bow string, insulting an official… They move the narrative forward in interesting ways.
I think for me the issue is I would rather play Kingdom Death Monster if I want that goal. I am not sure rp based ttrpgs fill that niche well.
I’ve never heard of KDM. But if your point is that there are better systems than DnD out there you’ll find no argument from me.
More that KDM does the job for dealing with the idea of “stuff goes wrong”. The games mechanics are built around it. Gear is important, characters are not. Which means stuff can go really bad very fast.
I think DnD does heroic fantasy really well.
I’ve been mostly playing Pathfinder 1e for years, we use the same system. It’s great when it does happen though.
“So uh, did you remember to sheath your weapon after the last fight? Well, you didn’t explicitly say that you did…”
So you just stabbed the guy with the mighty long spear of far-reaching doom…
“Ah fuck. I accidentally extended my Rod of Collapsing into Marvin’s face.”
“Awww man I just shot Marvin in the face”
Say it with me, folks.
Don’t point the gun at anything you’re not ready to shoot at.
And…
Keep your finger outside the trigger guard until you’re ready to shoot.
RIP Marvin.
SPOILERS For those who haven’t seen Pulp Fiction, he accidentally shoots and kills the man in the back seat.
My favorite MadTV sketch.
