• 9 Posts
  • 51 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
Cake day: June 23rd, 2023



  • I doubt the intelligence they transferred is only about the 12, given the size and immediacy of the reaction. Those are the ones they were able to most easily prove using Hamas’ own footage of October 7th.

    My guess is they passed a list with a lot more than 12 to each of those countries, and said “watch how many they fire”.

    Bottom line is that it isn’t in Israel’s best interests to stop all aid - they want to avoid a true humanitarian crisis (as opposed to the current threat of one) to achieve the war goals: return the hostages and destroy Hamas. UNRWA is best positioned to provide aid, but the proof on the ground is that they aren’t distributing that aid effectively at all and people are suffering as a result.




  • Cynical take: maybe don’t employ terrorists

    Real take: UNRWA staffers will be busy scrubbing their socials for the next week instead of actually handing out aid. Of course, they aren’t exactly distributing the aid anyways so I guess it will make fuckall difference. They’ll complain about it and blame all their troubles on it anyways. Bottom line is that aid won’t get to the people who need it until Hamas stops preventing it from reaching those in need.







  • Don’t underestimate people who have a vested interest in one side of a story and are willing to sacrifice anything to push that agenda.

    That and the danger that a group will take their status and abuse it to push a particular agenda despite evidence to the contrary. At that point they’re not fact checking - they’re actively pushing disinformation.





  • On October 7th, Hamas and PIJ militants attacked 20+ civilian communities and killed over 10% of the civilian population of the entire region with the explicit purpose of ethnically cleansing the area, along with thousands of rockets targeting civilian population centers across Israel.

    The civilian casualties in Gaza are a very sad fact of combat in a densely populated urban area, and are not being intentionally targeted by Israel alongside explicit declarations and very public military orders that “civilians are not to be targeted”. So far, around 1% of the civilian population of Gaza has been killed.

    So yeah, very different. They are the awful realities of war. Some of them are likely avoidable, but a large number of them are not, especially given Hamas’ tactics and doctrine of embedding within civilian populations.


  • Here’s the short list of Hamas’ war crimes that are part of their regular military doctrine:

    • Indirect fire that intentionally targets civilians
    • Indirect fire that intentionally targets protected infrastructure - medical, educational, and scientific
    • Conducting indirect fire from within protected infrastructure - medical, educational, and scientific
    • Taking civilian hostages
    • Intentionally targeting civilian population due to their nationality and/or religion
    • The systemic use of child soldiers
    • Coordination and housing of military efforts from within protected infrastructure - medical, educational, and scientific
    • Manufacturing weapons within protected infrastructure - medical , educational, and scientific
    • The use of medical transport to convey military forces during a military operation for operational purposes and not medical ones
    • Incitement to genocide
    • Incentivizing war crimes by paying larger pensions to their members (and their families) who commit atrocities

    These are the things they have done so much that it is clearly part of their military doctrine and policies, and not even remotely defensible as “one off” behavior of irregular forces.