Only for attack rolls. Ability checks and saves do not crit fail (or succeed) and reliable talent treats rolls for ability checks that add proficiency bonus as 10 at the lowest regardless, so even if a 1 were a crit fail, it wouldn’t matter.

Agreed, Laserllama did most of 5e’s classes a kindness. I prefer those to the PHB content.

It tends to make more sense in mid-to-low magic campaigns where the item you want might not be readily available, but 5e’s rules around magic items are notoriously underbaked. The reason they gave is that 5e is built around not needing magic items, but I’ve never played a game that doesn’t use them.

Vumans get a feat, which is arguably one of the strongest abilities. Base humans are notoriously weak though.

I think they’re both winners.

Found the elf.

Fuck, ain’t that the truth?

‘Normal D&D character’ is an oxymoron.

I’ve heard “because I like the sound of dice hitting the table.”

I feel bad for these players because it’s obvious a shitty rugpull-lover DM got to them first with a humiliation conga campaign. You know the type, where you run into all the homebrew mindfuck creatures people like to post because the DM thinks an endless deluge of trauma and ambushes is good storytelling, and then fall back on “Challenging players is the DM’s job!” Bro I’m here to tell a story, you think my level 3 warlock whose two invocations are “talk to animals” and “instant disguise” is built to get violated by a false hydra?