There’s nothing in Blades that requires you to run it in Doskvol, but that setting does have a few things going for it that makes Blades easier to run. Firstly, the players can’t just nope out of the city and lie low for a while in the countryside. They’re forced to deal with Doskvol all the time. Secondly, there are real and immediate consequences to murder and death. This incentivizes the players to at least attempt non-lethal methods. Of these, only the pressure cooker environment is really crucial for a game of Blades. The rest of the setting adapts just fine. You could, for example, run Blades in a post-nuclear war 1950s era New Orleans where the surrounding lands are surrounded by nuclear fallout. The city, however, survives due to protections conferred by devils.
Doskvol is just a tad too dark for Arcane, I do agree there. You don’t necessarily have to adapt Blades itself tho. Have you taken a look at a|state RPG? It also uses the Forged in the Dark engine but is a little more lighthearted. In that game, the crew are troublemakers trying to make one corner of a hellish urban landscape into a better place. The system makes caring as important as fighting. I think you might have better success with that system.
There’s nothing in Blades that requires you to run it in Doskvol, but that setting does have a few things going for it that makes Blades easier to run. Firstly, the players can’t just nope out of the city and lie low for a while in the countryside. They’re forced to deal with Doskvol all the time. Secondly, there are real and immediate consequences to murder and death. This incentivizes the players to at least attempt non-lethal methods. Of these, only the pressure cooker environment is really crucial for a game of Blades. The rest of the setting adapts just fine. You could, for example, run Blades in a post-nuclear war 1950s era New Orleans where the surrounding lands are surrounded by nuclear fallout. The city, however, survives due to protections conferred by devils.
Doskvol is just a tad too dark for Arcane, I do agree there. You don’t necessarily have to adapt Blades itself tho. Have you taken a look at a|state RPG? It also uses the Forged in the Dark engine but is a little more lighthearted. In that game, the crew are troublemakers trying to make one corner of a hellish urban landscape into a better place. The system makes caring as important as fighting. I think you might have better success with that system.